Tax on overseas companies and foreign trusts
Successful business owners rarely come home with just one tax entity. Often there is a trading company, an investment holding company and a trust are a common combination. Each has its own Australian tax position, and that position can change when you move, even if nothing in the structure changes.
When an overseas company becomes an Australian resident
A company incorporated overseas can still be an Australian resident for tax. Apart from incorporation, there are two routes. Both require the company to carry on business in Australia:
- its central management and control is in Australia; or
- shareholders who are Australian residents control its voting power.
Central management and control means the high-level decisions: strategy, major contracts, investment decisions, finance, dividends and senior appointments. The ATO’s view, in TR 2018/5, is that a company which carries on business, and has its central management and control in Australia, carries on business here for this test, even if its trading or investing happens overseas.
If an Australian-resident company is also resident where it was set up, both countries may tax its profits. A proposal to change the company residency test has been announced, but it is not law.
Who really makes the decisions
The courts look at who makes the decisions, not where the minutes say the meeting was held.
In Esquire Nominees (1973), offshore directors followed advice from Australian accountants, but would have refused any instruction they thought improper. The company was managed offshore. In Bywater Investments (2016), the High Court found that overseas directors were rubber-stamping decisions made in Australia. The companies were Australian residents.
If you want a company to stay foreign, the overseas directors need real authority, real information and real meetings, and they must use them. That addresses the management route only. If you own the company and its business is carried on in Australia, for example through your own work here, the voting power route must also be examined.
If the company stays foreign: the CFC rules
When Australian residents control a foreign company, it is a controlled foreign company (CFC). Some of its income can be taxed to you each year, even without a dividend.
The income caught is mainly passive or “tainted” income: interest, dividends, rent, royalties, gains on investments, and some sales and services involving related parties or Australian residents. A trading company that passes the active income test generally has little attributed. Whether it passes depends on its actual income, customers and related-party dealings.
An investment holding company generally fails the active income test. Its investment income can then be taxed to you every year, whether it pays a dividend. Different rules apply to companies resident in seven listed countries.
Working in Australia
Salary for work you do in Australia is generally Australian-source income, subject to any tax treaty. This is normally the case even if the project your working on is in another country. The company may also have a permanent establishment in Australia if its business is carried on through a fixed place here, such as your home office, depending on the treaty and the facts.
Overseas trusts: two separate questions
The first question is how the trust itself is taxed.
- A trust is generally an Australian resident trust for a year if a trustee is an Australian resident at any time in that year, or if its central management and control is in Australia. A deceased estate of a person (like your parents) can become taxable in Australia if you’re the trustee – even if none of the deceased assets are connected to Australia.
- If you are an individual trustee, your own residency is directly relevant. If the trustee is a company, the question is the company’s residency and where the trust’s central management and control is exercised. A director’s move can matter, but does not automatically make the trust resident.
- Where trustees merely implement decisions made by beneficiaries or others in Australia, where the trust’s real central management and control sits needs careful examination.
- Unit trusts have a different residency test for CGT.
- When a trust becomes resident for CGT purposes, its eligible assets can receive a market value cost base under section 855-50.
The second question is how you are taxed as a beneficiary.
- Section 99B can tax amounts paid to, or applied for, a beneficiary who is an Australian resident at any time in the income year. A distribution received before your residency starts can still be caught if you become a resident later in the same Australian income year. The ATO’s compliance approach in PCG 2024/3 covers this case.
- The trust’s market value reset does not, by itself, remove the beneficiary’s possible exposure under section 99B. Under TD 2024/9 (Example 7), the ATO uses the original cost base when working out the section 99B reductions, so gains made before the trust became resident can still be taxed when distributed.
- An interest charge can apply where the amount comes from untaxed income of a non-resident trust.
- If you transferred property to a foreign trust, the transferor trust rules can tax you on its income each year. Returning former residents generally cannot use an exclusion available to some first-time residents.
Realising a gain before a trustee becomes resident does not solve this on its own. For trusts, the review should be done before the Australian income year in which you expect to return.
Each option needs to be assessed for its commercial consequences, its tax cost in both countries and the anti-avoidance rules, including Part IVA. Commercial objectives are relevant but do not, by themselves, prevent Part IVA from applying.
Illustrative example: an overseas investment holding company
Lets take the case of a business owner holds 100% of a holding company resident in Monaco. It holds listed shares, bonds, managed fund units and a rental property, earning about $400,000 a year. It has $2 million of retained profits. The owner moves to Perth and continues to make the investment decisions.
If the investment decisions are made in Perth, the company may be an Australian resident and taxed here on its worldwide income. If it stays foreign, it is a CFC, and most of its $400,000 is likely to be taxed to the owner each year. Its $2 million of retained profits is a separate issue: paid as a dividend after the owner becomes resident, it is generally taxable (Part 2).
The structure, the management arrangements and the dividend timing need to be decided together, before the move. An active trading company would be tested differently under the active income test.
Checklist before you return
- Map each company and trust: owners, directors, trustees and beneficiaries.
- Decide where each company will actually be managed, and test the voting power route.
- Test the CFC position on actual figures, especially for investment holding companies.
- Review each foreign trust before the income year of return: trustee residency, accumulated amounts and expected distributions.
- Change trustees or directors only after the effect on both questions is understood.
- Obtain advice in the other country at the same time.
FAQ’s
Yes, if it carries on business in Australia and is either managed and controlled here or controlled by Australian-resident shareholders.
Possibly, each year, under the CFC rules. Investment income is the main type of income they catch.
Not necessarily. Section 99B can apply if you become resident at any time in the same income year.
Already back in Australia?
How your companies are managed now, and what your trusts distribute this year, decide the current position. We can review both before the next distribution or board decision.
Talk to us before the move
Planning to return to Australia? Our [pre-return tax planning review] maps your residency date, overseas entities, investments and pension arrangements before irreversible transactions occur. Before you change how your companies are run, or a trust makes a distribution, ask us to review company management, CFC exposure, trust residence and planned distributions. Where trusts are involved, start before the Australian income year in which you expect to return.